Ananthkumar Hegde, Pragya Thakur, Ramesh Bidhuri — why BJP denied tickets to Hindutva firebrands
6 min read
New Delhi/Bengaluru: Former Union minister and 6-time MP Anantkumar Hegde is the hottest among ‘firebrand’ leaders lacking from the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) record of 407 candidates for the Lok Sabha election.Regarded for his fiery speeches, usually concentrating on minorities, Hegde was a single of the earliest poster boys of Hindutva in Karnataka. But his fashion of politics, which acquired him notoriety and recognition and even a spot in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, also led to his downfall. Vishweshwara Hegde Kageri was alternatively selected this time for the Uttara Kannada Lok Sabha seat.
Other folks on this list — or, not in it — are Pragya Thakur from Madhya Pradesh, Parvesh Sahib Singh and Ramesh Bidhuri from Delhi, Prathap Simha and Nalin Kumar Kateel from Karnataka between other people who vociferously propagated polarising narratives or courted controversies.


Clearly show Comprehensive Report


The determination to drop some of these sitting down MPs, senior BJP leaders say, was for the reason that of the “awkward” predicament some of them set them selves and the bash in.
“For the social gathering, winnability is definitely the aim but the management also ensured that people who experienced put the bash in a place because of to their provocative statements and developed unneeded controversies have been also kept out of the checklist. In this, regardless of whether it is Pragya Thakur, MP from Bhopal, or Ramesh Bidhuri who was always in the spotlight for his controversial remarks no matter if in community or even in Parliament. The party also denied tickets to all those people MPs, owing to which it had to appear on the backfoot,” mentioned a central BJP chief.
Also Go through: In its latest listing, BJP fields Dharmendra Pradhan & Naveen Jindal, drops Gen VK Singh & Varun Gandhi
‘Realm of maryada’
In the operate up to the 2019 Lok Sabha election, Thakur experienced in contrast Ashok Chakra awardee and Maharashtra Anti-Terrorism Squad chief Hemant Karkare with Ravan and Kans. Karkare was killed in the course of the 26/11 Mumbai terrorist attacks simply because he was ‘cursed’ for arresting her in a case relating to the 2008 Malegaon blast scenario, she had stated. Whether it was urging Hindus to maintain weapons at household to give befitting replies to people who attack their homes or contacting Nathuram Godse a ‘patriot’, Thakur hardly ever held again.
Bidhuri was pulled up for his communal slurs versus Bahujan Samaj Social gathering (BSP) MP Danish Ali, now with the Congress, on the floor of the Lok Sabha. “During the cabinet meetings, throughout the Parliamentary get together or even in BJP’s interior meetings, the PM utilised to make it a stage to spotlight that the aim should not be on them but the procedures and advancement perform carried out by the federal government,” mentioned another senior BJP chief. “Whether it is Thakur, Bidhuri or Verma, all 3 made needless controversies not only outside the house but within Parliament way too. The motion in dropping these massive names is to exhibit that everyone requires to adhere to particular principles and at a time when the occasion is going through a joint opposition, it will not consider any likelihood.”Earlier this thirty day period, Hegde explained that the BJP needs 400 seats to assist get a the vast majority in the Rajya Sabha and alter the Structure. The BJP distanced alone from this remark, terming it as the MPs particular viewpoint which did not replicate that of the get together.
In an interview with ThePrint, Hegde explained he stood by his 2017 remarks to adjust the Constitution, unwilling to soften his stand on an issue that charge him his ministerial berth. Political analysts also stage out that this is PM Modi’s way of making sure a selected decorum is managed and that the concentrate remains on the operate of the govt and the get together, not the person. “PM Modi has been pointing it out for really some time and even in his cabinet conferences and parliamentary party conferences, he instructed BJP MPs to not make any controversial statements. He has fairly asked them to concentrate on policy linked concerns and troubles of growth. This has, in simple fact, become a component of the political structure of the BJP. In truth, the PM has been inquiring parliamentarians to observe a primary code of carry out of BJP politics which is to not make any provocative statement,” Badri Narayan, political analyst and professor, Govind Ballabh Pant Social Science Institute, Allahabad, told ThePrint. “The elected MPs at a time had commenced contemplating that they can do just about anything and that they will get away with it as they can win their constituency. By denying tickets to a quantity of this sort of controversial MPs, the PM has proven zero tolerance for those who have interaction in controversial statements. In a way, the PM is location an case in point and this will guarantee that MPs observe it. Opposing one thing is great, but it has to be finished in the realm of ‘maryada’. The MPs are not only symbolizing by themselves but the party and the PM much too.”
A third BJP leader claimed in quite a few scenarios, anti-Muslim opinions impacted relations further than the country’s shores. “India and the UAE, for occasion, have made a really close partnership. In simple fact, India has been engaged quite closely with all Gulf nations. Controversial statements hurt these relations. At a time when the social gathering is self-assured of returning to electrical power, it doesn’t want to have this baggage and consequently these leaders were being dropped,” the chief mentioned. ‘Firebrands not a scarce resource for BJP’
The chilly shoulder to a part of so-called firebrand leaders is just a coincidence and not a reflection of any re-believe in just the BJP about its polarising strategies, say some analysts. For occasion, Tejasvi Surya and Shobha Karandlaje have secured tickets from Bengaluru. A notable Hindutva figure, Madhavi Latha is the BJP’s prospect to consider on Asaduddin Owaisi of All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) in Hyderabad. “I really do not assume the party’s choice to fall some of them has nearly anything to do with them becoming firebrands. In every case, the good reasons are distinct,” A.Narayana, political analyst and school at Bengaluru’s Azim Premji University, instructed ThePrint.
He added that firebrand leaders are ‘dime-a-dozen’ inside of the BJP and that leaders who mostly preserve a persona of tough line Hindutva are “not a rare resource”. Most of the leaders dropped are not first-time MPs both and have secured tickets in past elections in spite of wading into controversies. “Just due to the fact the BJP has dropped some of them does not necessarily mean it will remain away from these type of politics. They have a selection of men and women who can fill these areas,” Narayana asserted. However, a person of the BJP leaders claimed that the denial of tickets was more to do with retaining anti-incumbency in thoughts as the party wants to satisfy the goal of ‘400 paar’ and not for the reason that of the statements built by the leaders.
“Every seat counts and owing to anti-incumbency, it was felt that some sitting MPs ought to be changed. It experienced very little to do with their feedback. For instance, Ramesh Bidhuri was provided poll obligation for a district in Rajasthan immediately after the controversy. Equally, Parvesh Verma has been built co-incharge of Rajasthan election, and Bidhuri has also been designed co-incharge of Uttar Pradesh, which is a significant point out for the party,” countered the chief.“Yes, as significantly as Pragya Thakur is involved, there ended up grievances with regards to her from the point out device by itself.”The BJP also maintains that a amount of these leaders ended up in fact “punished” for placing the bash in a location. “There are certain rules and norms which are to be followed by all whether you are an MP, minister or social gathering business office bearers. You have to adhere to the occasion line and if you cross the. Bash will take a phone on that,” reported R.P. Singh, countrywide get together spokesperson of the BJP.
(Edited by Tony Rai)
Also Browse: Congress fields Kharge’s son-in-legislation from Kalaburagi, provides tickets to kids of Karnataka ministers
